Back to Posts

How your leadership style can either make or break your startup

Nearly one in four startups fails because the founder never learned to lead. CB Insights puts the number at 23 %. Founders start companies; leaders build them. ...

Malcolm Paul
Malcolm Paul
5 min read
Share this article:

The One‑Sentence Reality Check

Nearly one in four startups fail because the founder never learned to lead. CB Insights puts the number at 23%. Founders start companies; leaders build them. In early-stage startups, your leadership style isn't just a personal trait, it's a business multiplier. It determines your ability to build a high-functioning team, adapt to rapid change, and maintain momentum through uncertainty. As the saying goes, "People don't leave companies; they leave managers."

Why Leadership Style Matters

In the startup world, where resources are limited and speed matters, leadership gaps can show up quickly. Founders wear many hats, but failing to evolve from "doer" to "leader" creates serious risks:

  • Self leadership and self-awareness are prized by high-performers
  • Poor delegation limits scalability and leads to burnout
  • Inconsistent vision confuses teams and slows execution
  • A lack of transparency erodes trust
  • Weak decision-making kills momentum

Let's bring this home with a few real-world anecdotes from our work at NITM:

  • Slow decision-making led to frustration and drops in confidence. Teams were uncertain whether to act or wait, which undermined morale and team synergy
  • A constantly shifting vision and mission caused multiple teams to stall, unsure of how to prioritize. Strategic drift can be fatal at early stages
  • Lack of transparency between leadership's stated goals and actual execution led to a loss of trust across the company. Without trust, commitment fades
  • Failure to delegate created idle time for some and busy work for others. Without clear ownership and autonomy, the company became over-reliant on the founder. This is an unsustainable dynamic

Harvard Business Review echoes this: 60 % of startup failures stem from people problems, not technology (Eisenmann, Why Startups Fail). Leadership is the glue that holds it all together.

Action takeaway: Time every major decision you make this week. If it's >48 hours, identify the blocker and remove it.

The Soft‑Skill Stack of High‑Impact Founders

Soft skills reign supreme in early-stage environments. While hard skills get you to launch, soft skills help you scale. Critical leadership traits include:

  • Clear communication and trustworthiness
  • Decisive action and consistency
  • Accountability and transparency
  • Empathy and relationship building

Above all, successful founders demonstrate self-awareness. By recognizing their strengths and shortcomings, they can adequately lead themselves, improve personally, or hire strategically to fill gaps.

Action takeaway: Ask one team‑mate for unfiltered feedback before Friday.

How a Clear Style Helps You Execute

Effective leadership accelerates decisions, maximizes existing talent, preserves runway, and fosters a culture primed for rapid innovation. In other words, Startups demand versatility. You need team members who wear multiple hats, and you must be the glue that binds them. A strong leadership style enables you to:

  • Lead yourself effectively before leading others
  • Delegate with confidence
  • Uncover hidden talents in your team (e.g., a quiet engineer with marketing potential)
  • Foster a culture of accountability and trust
  • Inspire others to work toward the company's vision

Ultimately, it frees you to work on the business, not just in it.

Action takeaway: List three tasks someone else could do 80 % as well. Hand off one tomorrow.

Leadership Styles at a Glance

Not all styles are appropriate for the task at hand, the moment, or the stage of the company. A mix of various styles can be more effective than leaning into any single one.

StyleBenefitEarly‑Stage Risk
CoachingEncourages growth and leverages individual strengthsSlower short‑term output
AuthoritativeAligns around visionCan tip into micromanagement
VisionaryInspires innovation and motivates by painting a compelling futureNeeds translation into roadmaps
ServantBoosts engagement and prioritizes team needsDecision latency. Powerful but can slow down decision-making
DemocraticSurfaces ideas and empowers team inputAnalysis paralysis. Can enhance creativity but slow responses
TransactionalClarifies incentives. Clear rewards and punishmentsLimited intrinsic motivation. Effective short-term but less inspiring
Autocratic / CoerciveRapid crisis controlCripples and destroys creativity, innovation & trust
BureaucraticProcess reliabilitySlows growth with excessive rules. Lethal to speed
Laissez‑faireAutonomyLeaves teams directionless and unaccountable

"Leaders who master multiple styles, switching like a golfer selecting clubs, deliver the best results" —Daniel Goleman, Leadership That Gets Results (HBR, 2000)

Action takeaway: Circle two styles you default to. Ask your team which style they see.

Quick Founder Self‑Assessment

Answer Yes or No:

  1. My team can recite our mission in one sentence
  2. Decisions on critical issues take < 48 hours
  3. Team members regularly give me unfiltered feedback
  4. No task on my plate could be done 80 % as well by someone else
  5. Our remote/hybrid teammates feel as informed as on‑site staff

Three or more "No" answers = time for a leadership tune‑up.

From Insight to Action: Starter Tools

ToolImplementation
Transparent decision logNotion or Confluence page updated after each leadership meeting
Continuous feedback loop15Five or Officevibe pulse surveys
Async vision alignmentLoom video briefs & monthly or quarterly OKR check‑ins

How can we help?

At NITM we focus on intersecting technology with business goals. This means ensuring that the engineers, technology, roadmap, and efficiency of the technology needs are aligned with the founder's vision and mission.

  • 30‑min Leadership Style Audit: Personalised scorecard + next steps.
  • Founder Advisory: Transition from chief‑doer to chief‑leader without dropping balls.
  • Team Architecture & Hiring: Map roles to your evolving style and growth plan.
  • Tech Strategy Alignment: Ensure product roadmaps match the vision you're communicating.

Additional Resources

What's next?

Stay tuned for more insights on effective leadership tactics tailored specifically for early-stage startup founders.

Related

Reflecting on the Future: AI, NITM, Entrepreneurship
Read More

Reflecting on the Future: AI, NITM, Entrepreneurship

The world is changing way too fast.

Malcolm Paul
Malcolm Paul
Why understanding the value of chatbots is critical to your success
Read More

Why understanding the value of chatbots is critical to your success

A chatbot is software that can be used with either visual, voice or text to interact with your users. Chatbots can be found in every part of life, from popular voice assistants such as Alexa and Google Home to messaging platforms such as Slack, Skype, Facebook Messenger and more. They offer a unique way to interact with potential users and could provide extra value to your customers with little effort.

Malcolm Paul
Malcolm Paul
Protect your Ass(ets)
Read More

Protect your Ass(ets)

As a business owner, entrepreneur, founder, partner or person responsible for the spending of your money, the most dangerous things out there are a waste of your time, money and energy. While you can get more of and make up for some of each, do you really want to though? Today we’re gonna talk about one of the worst cases of time, money and energy suck we’ve experienced so far: The scam known as T-Mobile Travel.

Malcolm Paul
Malcolm Paul